nd.gov - The Official Portal for North Dakota State Government
North Dakota: Legendary. Follow the trail of legends
   
 
North Dakota Insurance Department
Jon Godfread, Commissioner
Twitter Flickr YouTube RSS
communications prescription shic healthcare enforcement compliance forms special
consumers producers companies
Home > Consumers > Auto > Auto Insurance Cost Comparison Survey
Auto Insurance Cost Comparison Survey
March 2017
 
Our survey shows how much "Good" drivers and "Higher Risk" drivers will pay for a six month auto insurance policy, in five different areas of the state.
 
We invited 20 Auto insurance companies to take part in our survey.  The companies listed in our survey sell more than 80 percent of the auto insurance purchased in North Dakota.
 
THE AUTO INSURANCE COMPANIES INCLUDED IN THIS SURVEY WERE CHOSEN BASED ON THEIR VOLUME OF BUSINESS IN NORTH DAKOTA.  BEING ON THIS LIST IS NOT A "RECOMMENDATION" BY THE INSURANCE COMMISSIONER'S OFFICE.  YOU SHOULD NOT LIMIT YOUR SHOPPING TO THE COMPANIES ON OUR LIST.
 
Examples 1, 2, 3 and 4 are "good" drivers, who will be accepted by most low‑cost companies.  They have excellent driving records, drive an average number of miles per year, and have "family‑type" cars.  We list only the low cost companies that will insure these drivers.
 
Examples 5 and 6 also have "good" drivers, but have an additional youthful driver.  For these examples, we list both the low and high cost companies that will accept these drivers.
 
Example 7 shows how much an elderly driver with a clean driving record will pay for insurance.
 
Examples 8, 9 and 10 have less than perfect driving records, drive a "sports car", or are younger, and they pay more for auto insurance.  Only “higher risk" companies agreed to insure these drivers.
 
Insurance companies have different methods of rating each driver, so one company may have the lowest price for one of our examples, and yet be comparatively higher in another.  Many factors, such as where you live, your age, sex, marital status, driving record, credit score, use of vehicle, discounts and surcharges, make and model of car can affect how much you pay for auto insurance.  That's why it pays to "shop around" for auto insurance.

 
HOW TO UNDERSTAND THIS SURVEY
The prices shown in our survey are the amounts paid every six months as of January 1, 2017. We describe "important company differences" that affect the quoted prices, on the last two pages of our survey.  We would also like to caution that this survey represents the rates that were in effect as of a certain point in time.  Since the publication of this survey, rates may have changed.
 
WHAT THE COVERAGES MEAN
LIABILITY covers someone else's losses if you are legally responsible.  BODILY INJURY covers sickness, injury or death of another person.  PROPERTY DAMAGE covers damage, destruction, or loss of use of another person's property.  Our survey uses a "split limit" coverage, which provides separate limits for bodily injury and property damage.
 
PERSONAL INJURY PROTECTION (PIP) is a form of "no‑fault" insurance.  PIP covers medical expenses, wage loss and other costs, no matter who caused the accident.
 
UNINSURED MOTORIST (UM) coverage will pay for a bodily injury claim that you sustain caused by a driver without insurance.
 
UNDERINSURED MOTORIST (UIM) coverage will pay for a bodily injury claim caused by a driver whose liability coverage is less than the amount of underinsured motorist coverage you carry.
 
COLLISION covers damage to your car caused by hitting something.
 
COMPREHENSIVE covers damage to your car if the loss isn't caused by a collision, but by other unforeseeable causes such as hail, wind, fire, etc.
 
COVERAGE LIMITS ‑ EXAMPLES 1 through 8
LIABILITY ‑ BODILY INJURY:  $100,000 limit for injury to another person/$300,000 limit for injuries to all persons.
 
LIABILITY ‑ PROPERTY DAMAGE:  $50,000 limit.
 
UNINSURED MOTORIST (UM) ‑ BODILY INJURY: $100,000 limit for injury to one person/ $300,000 limit for injuries to all persons.
 
UNDERINSURED MOTORIST (UIM) ‑ BODILY INJURY:  Limits equal to the Uninsured Motorist limit.
 
PERSONAL INJURY PROTECTION (PIP):  $30,000 limit.
 
COLLISION:  $500 Deductible.
 
COMPREHENSIVE:  $250 Deductible.
 
COVERAGE LIMITS  – EXAMPLEs 9 and 10
LIABILITY ‑ BODILY INJURY:  $25,000 limit for injury to another person/$50,000 limit for injuries to all persons.
 
LIABILITY ‑ PROPERTY DAMAGE:  $25,000 limit.
 
UNINSURED MOTORIST (UM) ‑ BODILY INJURY: $25,000 limit for injury to one person/ $50,000 limit for injuries to all persons.
 
UNDERINSURED MOTORIST (UIM) ‑ BODILY INJURY:  Limits equal to the Uninsured Motorist limit.
 
PERSONAL INJURY PROTECTION (PIP):  $30,000 limit.
 
The following examples show each company's six month premium and include discounts for multi‑car and safe driver when appropriate.

EXAMPLE NUMBER 1:   Single Male, Age 25.  Drives 2009 Ford F150 Lariat 4X4 four miles each way to work, five days per week.  Annual mileage = 15,000.  Clean driving record for three years and excellent credit history.  There are no other drivers in household.
 
                                                      Remainder     Bismarck/           Grand
Company Name          Fargo          of State        Mandan            Forks          Minot

Allied                                $433               $474              $488              $445          $513

Allstate                              $600               $577              $775              $576          $583

American Family             $490               $472              $547              $472          $519

Center Mutual                  $694               $603              $659              $636          $655

Garrison Prop & Cas  $607             $618              $566              $551          $513

GEICO                               $440               $564              $489               $437          $506

GEICO Indemnity             $898            $1,216          $1,020               $893      $1,036

Grinnell Select                  $631               $794             $759               $678          $743

Metropolitan                      $624               $736             $847               $785          $743

Mid Century                       $354               $386             $392               $345          $433

Nat’l Farmers Union         $479               $603             $565                $479          $550

Nodak Mutual                    $267               $346             $354                $338          $355

North Star Mutual        $525               $511             $599                $513         $524

Progressive Direct            $273               $312             $320                $287         $342

Progressive NW                $296               $347             $362                 $315        $387

Safeco                                 $578              $665              $624                 $570        $591

State Farm Fire                  $604              $828              $645                  $573       $724

State Farm Mutual             $553              $778              $595                  $528        $669

USAA                                   $400              $430              $388                  $384        $349

USAA Casualty                  $407              $436              $395                  $380        $354

EXAMPLE NUMBER 2:   Single Female, Age 30.  Drives 2011 Acura TL four miles each way to work, five days per week.  Annual mileage = 10,000.  Clean driving record for three years and excellent credit history.  There are no other drivers in household.

                                                      Remainder     Bismarck/           Grand
Company Name          Fargo          of State        Mandan            Forks          Minot

Allied                                 $367               $405             $413            $376           $436

Allstate                              $647               $621             $819            $614           $624

American Family             $496               $488             $560             $474          $535

Center Mutual                  $571               $513             $531             $503          $535

Garrison Prop & Cas      $408               $421             $381              $370         $350

GEICO                               $310               $415             $349              $307         $357

GEICO Indemnity             $759            $1,047            $865               $751         $870

Grinnell Select                  $398               $514            $486               $429         $472

Metropolitan                      $546                $646           $749               $684         $652

Mid Century                       $272                $348           $350                $300        $380

Nat’l Farmers Union         $446                $590           $547               $437        $514

Nodak Mutual                    $230                $332           $323               $300        $319

North Star Mutual              $417                $410           $477               $409        $416

Progressive Direct            $261                $305           $313               $277         $330

Progressive NW                $270                $329            $342              $292         $359

Safeco                                 $623                $776            $705              $629         $664

State Farm Fire                  $448                 $632           $482               $428        $542

State Farm Mutual             $411                 $595            $445              $395        $502

USAA                                   $328                 $357            $319               $314       $290

USAA Casualty                  $330                 $359            $321               $308       $291

EXAMPLE NUMBER 3:  Married couple, both age 35.  Husband drives 2008 Dodge Ram 4X4 1500 to work 5 miles each way, five days per week.  Annual mileage = 12,000.  Wife drives 2009 Ford Taurus to work 2 miles each way, five days per week.  Annual mileage = 7,000. Both have a clean record for last three years and excellent credit history.  There are no other drivers in household.

                                                      Remainder     Bismarck/          Grand
Company Name          Fargo          of State        Mandan           Forks          Minot

Allied                                 $450               $495             $499            $462           $517

Allstate                              $663               $627             $842             $633           $634

American Family             $566               $539             $655             $519           $579

Center Mutual                  $754              $657              $694             $664           $710

Garrison Prop & Cas       $526              $516              $481            $474            $444

GEICO                                $430              $564              $481            $427            $494

GEICO Indemnity           $1,054           $1,421          $1,193         $1,043        $1,204

Grinnell Select                  $628                $788             $754            $673           $733

Metropolitan                      $705                $840             $944            $912            $841

Mid Century                       $448                $493             $497             $432           $544

Nat’l Farmers Union         $563                $713             $676            $559           $640

Nodak Mutual                    $305                $414             $413             $390           $409

North Star Mutual              $546                $530             $621             $533          $545

Progressive Direct             $324                $389             $406            $350           $417 

Progressive NW                 $344                $434             $459            $379           $463

Safeco                                  $616                $761             $695             $619          $654

State Farm  Fire                  $559                $785             $600             $533          $672

State Farm Mutual              $514                $740             $554             $493          $622

USAA                                    $443                $459             $421             $420          $385

USAA Casualty                   $450                $465             $428             $416          $390

EXAMPLE NUMBER 4:  Married couple, both aged 65 and retired.  Husband drives 2013 Ford F-150 SuperCrew pickup.  Annual mileage = 10,000.  Wife drives 2009 Toyota Prius Hybrid.  Annual mileage = 4,000.  Both have clean records and excellent credit history.  There are no other drivers in household.

                                                      Remainder     Bismarck/          Grand
Company Name          Fargo          of State        Mandan           Forks          Minot

Allied                                $473                $531             $532           $488           $556

Allstate                             $731                $692             $893            $693           $700

American Family            $580                $559             $665            $541           $607

Center Mutual                 $736                $643             $696            $667           $716  

Garrison Prop & Cas      $562               $563              $519             $508          $479

GEICO                               $417               $592              $478            $416          $484
   
GEICO Indemnity         $1,367            $1,961           $1,579         $1,360       $1,579

Grinnell Select                 $578                $732              $697            $621         $679

Metropolitan                     $826                $987            $1,134         $1,058         $988

Mid Century                      $424                $534               $530           $451         $579

Nat’l Farmers Union        $674                $879              $822            $670         $780

Nodak Mutual                   $284                $399               $397            $368         $399

North Star Mutual             $599                $587               $682            $585         $597

Progressive Direct            $311                $373              $389            $335         $402

Progressive NW                $325                $402               $424           $354         $435

Safeco                                 $708                $919               $825           $721         $772

State Farm Fire                  $529                $753               $570           $507         $640

State Farm Mutual             $486                $711               $527           $468         $593

USAA                                   $483                $512               $464          $460         $424

USAA Casualty                  $489                $516               $469          $454          $428

EXAMPLE NUMBER 5:  Married couple ages 46 & 44 with Youthful driver.  Husband, age 46, drives 2009 Chevrolet Silverado pickup to work 8 miles each way, five days per week.  Annual mileage = 15,000.  Wife, age 44, drives 2009 Chevrolet HHR LT to work 5 miles each way, 5 days per week.  Annual mileage = 10,000.  Youthful driver, male, age 16, is a junior in High School, is an 'A' average student, and drives the pickup on an occasional basis.  All drivers have clean records.  Husband and wife have excellent credit history.  The teenage driver has no credit history.

                                                      Remainder     Bismarck/          Grand
Company Name          Fargo          of State        Mandan           Forks          Minot

Allied                                $692                $736              $766           $706            $802

Allstate                          $1,163             $1,075           $1,362       $1,096         $1,098  

American Family             $773                $738              $859           $755            $826

Center Mutual                  $892                $764              $831           $796            $835

Garrison Prop & Cas $1,165         $1,087          $1,023        $1,018            $949

GEICO                               $843             $1,083              $939           $839            $975

GEICO Indemnity         $1,841             $2,469           $2,085      $1,829          $2,124

Grinnell Select              $1,009             $1,281           $1,221      $1,085          $1,189

Metropolitan                  $2,350             $2,746           $3,164     $2,897           $2,804

Mid Century                      $865                 $961              $974        $874           $1,084

Nat’l Farmers Union        $865              $1,053              $994        $864              $967

Nodak Mutual                   $561                 $761              $764         $720             $760

North Star Mutual       $937                 $912           $1,069        $919            $937

Progressive Direct           $608                  $668              $681         $632            $753

Progressive NW               $625                   $700             $729         $658            $796

Safeco                             $1,541                $1,692         $1,613     $1,497         $1,534

State Farm Fire              $1,135                $1,476          $1,199    $1,066         $1,338

State Farm Mutual         $1,380                $1,101             $978    $1,230         $1,231

USAA                                  $831                    $814             $755      $764             $695

USAA Casualty                 $847                     $825             $768     $757             $706

EXAMPLE NUMBER 6:  Single Female, Age 48 with Youthful driver  drives 2009 Buick LaCrosse CXL to work 3 miles each way, five days per week.  Annual mileage = 18,000.  Youthful driver, male, age 16, is a junior in High School, is an 'A' average student, and drives the car on an occasional basis.  All drivers have clean records.  The female driver has excellent credit history.  The youthful driver has no credit history.

                                                      Remainder     Bismarck/          Grand
Company Name          Fargo          of State        Mandan           Forks          Minot

Allied                                $532               $557              $593           $545            $625

Allstate                             $717               $651              $772            $672           $669

American Family            $582               $555              $623             $588           $625

Center Mutual                $496               $408               $457            $444           $462

Garrison Prop & Cas  $1,016         $933              $877            $875           $816

GEICO                              $558              $686               $476            $553            $641
 
GEICO Indemnity        $1,242           $1,600            $1,388         $1,229        $1,423

Grinnell Select                $617               $756               $731             $659          $717

Metropolitan                 $1,745            $2,020            $2,347        $2,105       $2,077

Mid Century                     $566                $563              $572             $521         $640

Nat’l Farmers Union       $451                $546              $514            $450         $499

Nodak Mutual                  $332                $419               $431           $416         $426

North Star Mutual      $501                $483              $569            $492         $503   

Progressive Direct           $450                $482              $490           $461         $549

Progressive NW               $503                $550              $565           $521         $633

Safeco                             $1,433            $1,504            $1,460      $1,377      $1,394

State Farm Fire                  $816               $976               $848         $754         $939

State Farm Mutual             $742              $904                $774         $688         $858

USAA                                   $686              $653                $607         $618         $562

USAA Casualty                  $697              $660                $615         $610         $569

EXAMPLE NUMBER 7:  Single Female, Age 72   drives 2010 Lincoln Town Car.  Annual mileage = 5,000.  Clean driving record for three years and excellent credit history.

                                                      Remainder     Bismarck/          Grand
Company Name          Fargo          of State        Mandan           Forks          Minot

Allied                                $370               $405               $417           $380           $441

Allstate                             $569               $538                $674          $537           $544

American Family             $410              $403                $449          $403           $444

Center Mutual                  $412             $360                 $390          $374          $400

Garrison Prop & Cas       $432             $412                $384          $380          $357

GEICO                                $220             $281                $244          $218          $251
 
GEICO Indemnity             $668              $870                $748          $659         $758

Grinnell Select                  $328              $411                $393           $351        $384

Metropolitan                      $539              $634                $729          $674        $644

Mid Century                 $219             $250                 $252          $226         $282

Nat’l Farmers Union         $331             $392                 $372          $330         $362

Nodak Mutual                    $142             $186                 $189          $181         $189

North Star Mutual              $342              $334                $391          $336         $343

Progressive Direct             $224             $251                 $255          $233        $276

Progressive NW                 $221             $255                 $264          $234        $286

Safeco                                  $530             $624                  $578         $527        $548

State Farm Fire                   $368              $492                 $392         $349        $439

State Farm Mutual              $337              $461                 $361         $321       $405

USAA                                    $335               $333                $307         $309       $284

USAA Casualty                   $339               $336                $310         $304       $286

EXAMPLE 8:  Married couple, both age 25, with 2 young children at home.  Husband drives 2007 Toyota Solara eight miles to work each way, five days per week.  Annual mileage = 12,000.  Wife drives 2008 Ford Focus SE six miles to daycare and work each day, five days per week.  Annual mileage = 10,000.  The husband had an accident one year ago, causing $2,000 damage to another party.  The wife has a speeding ticket (45mph in a 35mph zone).

                                                      Remainder     Bismarck/          Grand
Company Name          Fargo          of State        Mandan           Forks          Minot

Allied                                $764               $825               $853            $785           $889

Allstate                              $885               $820           $1,026            $832          $834

American Standard        $738               $709               $824            $715          $789

Center Mutual                  $814               $709              $731            $697          $746

Garrison Prop & Cas      $727                $710             $657            $647          $608

GEICO                               $709                $922             $790            $701          $809

GEICO Indemnity          $1,348            $1,773          $1,513        $1,328       $1,528

Grinnell Mutual              $1,007            $1,229          $1,188        $1,074       $1,169

Metropolitan                   $1,426             $1,687         $1,925         $1,799      $1,702

Mid Century                 $838                 $974           $983            $ 888     $1,099

Nat’l Farmers Union         $729                 $888           $834             $727        $813

Nodak Mutual                    $433                 $576           $581             $551        $575

North Star Mutual              $705                 $681           $803              $689       $708

Progressive Direct            $557                  $625           $638             $582       $697

Progressive NW                $635                  $728           $754             $672       $817

Safeco                                 $677                 $777            $730             $664      $691

State Farm Fire                  $871               $1,103           $914             $814   $1,016

State Farm Mutual             $690                  $886           $727              $647      $808

USAA                                   $603                  $616           $563              $563       $518

USAA Casualty                  $610                  $621            $569              $555       $522

USAA General Ind             $682                  $668            $618              $624       $572

EXAMPLE NUMBER 9:  Single male, age 21.  Drives 2006 Ford Mustang five miles each way to work, five days per week.  Annual mileage = 12,000.  He has a speeding violation two years old (75mph in a 55 mph zone), a speeding violation one year old (45mph in a 25mph zone), and an "At Fault" accident causing $9,500 damage to a third party six months ago.  Driver has excellent credit history.  There are no other drivers in the household. DRIVER IS LOOKING FOR A “LIABILITY ONLY” POLICY.

                                                      Remainder     Bismarck/          Grand
Company Name          Fargo          of State        Mandan           Forks          Minot

Allied                                $554                $428             $549            $553           $542

Allstate                              $377               $308              $333            $361           $332

American Standard        $474               $410              $463             $510           $469

Center Mutual                  $352               $253              $269             $269           $295

Garrison Prop & Cas      $402                $312              $320            $334           $292

GEICO                               $396                $347              $397           $378            $422

GEICO Indemnity            $613                $534               $616           $589           $646
   
Metropolitan                     $828                $906              $912             $972          $927

Mid Century               $489                $466              $525             $496           $573

Nat’l Farmers Union       $344                $302              $321             $348            $320

Nodak Mutual                  $171                $117               $157            $185            $144

Progressive Direct           $251               $240               $245            $251            $273

Progressive NW               $237               $219               $229             $236            $263

Safeco                               $492               $416                $458             $436            $438

State Farm Fire                $752                $654               $730              $649           $769

USAA                          $254                $197                $203              $218           $185

USAA Casualty         $284                $220                $227              $237           $207

USAA General Ind          $324                $253                $258              $277           $235

EXAMPLE NUMBER 10:  Single male, age 40.  Drives 2010 Chevrolet Impala 10 miles each way to work, five days per week.  Annual mileage = 15,000.  Last month he was convicted of Driving Under the Influence (DUI).  He needs to make an "SR-22" filing to get his license back.  Driver has excellent credit history.  There are no other drivers in the household. DRIVER IS LOOKING FOR A “LIABILITY ONLY” POLICY.  
 
                                                      Remainder     Bismarck/          Grand
Company Name          Fargo          of State        Mandan           Forks          Minot

Allied                                $464                $371             $458            $464            $452

Allstate                             $286                $241             $259             $278            $258

American Standard       $222                 $206             $220             $231            $221

Center Mutual                $279                 $199              $198             $198            $218

Garrison Prop & Cas     $323                $250              $258              $269            $236

GEICO                              $324                $282              $325               $311           $348

Grinnell Select                $404                 $368              $406              $403          $394
  
Metropolitan                    $576                 $639              $640              $698           $649

Mid Century                     $291                 $254              $286              $270            $311

Nat’l Farmers Union       $172                 $154              $159             $171            $157

Nodak Mutual                  $162                  $110              $149             $175            $136

Progressive Direct           $154                 $147              $151             $154            $163

Progressive NW               $122                  $115              $119             $122            $135

Safeco                                $303                  $260              $282            $270            $271

USAA                                  $208                  $161              $167            $179            $153

USAA Casualty                 $223                  $172              $178           $186             $164

USAA General Ind            $215                  $167              $172           $185             $158

THE AUTOMOBILE INSURANCE "ASSIGNED RISK" PLAN
Some drivers cannot buy insurance from the companies listed in our survey.  If you cannot buy insurance in the open market from either a low cost or a high risk company, you may be eligible for the "assigned risk" plan.  This plan was designed to make insurance available for any driver who wants to buy it, regardless of their driving record.

You are eligible for coverage through the assigned risk plan, if:
 
            *  You are a resident of North Dakota.
            *  Your vehicle is registered in North Dakota.
            *  You have a current valid North Dakota drivers license.
            *  You have no unpaid automobile insurance premiums in the last twelve months.
 
The cost of the auto insurance through the assigned risk plan is usually higher, but coverage is available for all drivers who meet the eligibility requirements.  If you cannot get insurance on the open market, ask your agent or broker for assistance in contacting the North Dakota Auto Insurance Plan Office at:
 
North Dakota Automobile Insurance Plan
1 East Wacker Drive, Suite 3120
Chicago, IL 60601
Phone:  (888) 706 – 6100
Fax:  (312) 494 – 1750
Email:  ndaip@aipso.com
Website:  www.aipso.com/nd
 
IMPORTANT COMPANY DIFFERENCES
Mid-Century
          Electronic Funds (EFT) discount and ePolicy discount.
 
National Farmers Union Insurance
          All examples assume paid-in-full premiums.  Pro-active discount applied in all examples.
 
Nodak Mutual Insurance Company
            Nodak files annual rates; the six month premiums quoted in the examples are arrived at
by dividing the rates in half.  All risks were quoted on the EFT Payment Plan.
 
Progressive Direct/Progressive NorthwesternInsurance Companies
“Snapshot” discount applied to all rating examples

North Dakota Insurance Department
600 E. Boulevard Ave.
Bismarck, ND 58505-0320
Phone 701.328.2440
Toll free 800.247.0560
Fax 701.328.4880

Copyright © 2017 North Dakota Insurance Department
Contact us
About us
RSS feeds
Site map
Privacy policy
Security policy
Disclaimer